| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Michael Showalter | Coop / President Reagan (4) Coop (16) |
| Paul Rudd | Andy (16) |
| Zak Orth | JJ (16) |
| Marguerite Moreau | Katie (16) |
| Alexandra Stamler | |
| Isaak Presley | Kyle (14) |
| Samm Levine | |
| Josh Douglas | Rafi (14) |
| George Dalton | |
| Michael Blaiklock | Danny (14) |
| Thomas Barbusca | Drew (14) |
| Jason Schwartzman | Greg (14) |
| David Bloom | Kevin (14) |
| Lake Bell | Donna (14) |
| Molly Shannon | Gail (14) |
| Janeane Garofalo | Beth (14) |
| Bradley Cooper | Ben (14) |
| Michael Ian Black | McKinley (14) |
| Amy Poehler | Susie (14) |
| Dan Klein | Jeremy (12) |
| Hannah Friedman | Becky (12) |
| David Wain | Yaron (12) |
| Rich Sommer | Graham (12) |
| Eric Nenninger | Warner (12) |
| Josh Charles | Blake (12) |
| Christopher Meloni | Gene (6) Gene / Jonas (2) Jonas (6) |
| Nina Hellman | Nancy (12) |
| Elizabeth Banks | Lindsay (12) |
| Michaela Watkins | Rhonda (12) |
| Alysha Wheeler | Electro-City Chorus (12) |
| Kelly Sheerin | Electro-City Chorus (12) |
| Matthew Shaffer | Electro-City Chorus (12) |
| Beckie King | Electro-City Chorus (12) |
| Nick Drago | Electro-City Chorus (12) |
| Lou Becker | Electro-City Chorus (12) |
| John Slattery | Claude Dumet (12) |
| Chris Pine | Eric (10) |
| Ken Marino | Victor (10) |
| Joe Lo Truglio | Neil (10) |
| Hailey Sole | Amy (10) |
| A.D. Miles | Gary (10) |
| Logan Garretson | Piano Player (10) |
| Jon Hamm | The Falcon (8) |
| H. Jon Benjamin | Mitch (8) |
| Randall Park | Jeff (8) |
| Bettina Kenney | |
| Kristen Wiig | Courtney (6) |
| Michael Cera | Jim Stansel (6) |
| Kevin Sussman | Steve (6) |
| Marisa Ryan | Abby (6) |
| Jordan Peele | Alan (6) |
| Jessica Rogers | Whitney (4) |
| Barrett Mitchell | David (4) |
| Ryan Hafron | Tigerclaw Camp Counselor (4) |
| Christopher Clausi | Juror (4) |
| Beth Dover | Shari (4) |
| David Hyde Pierce | Assoc. Prof. Henry Neumann (4) |
| Judah Friedlander | Ron Von Kleinenstein (4) |
| Emily Killian | Graham's Date (4) |
| E.J. Callahan | |
| Weird Al Yankovic | Jackie Brazen (4) |
| Paul Scheer | Dave (4) |
| Jayma Mays | Jessica (4) |
| John Early | Logan (4) |
| Emily Skinner | Froggy (4) |
| Peter Salett | Guitar Dude (4) |
| Logistx | Breakdancer (4) |
| Mark Cirillo | JJ's Friend (4) |
| Ali Marsh | Carol (4) |
| Zandy Hartig | Denise (4) |
| Matthew Ballard | Stu (4) |
| Hugh Dane | Judge (2) |
| Bebe Wood | Young Abby (2) |
| Ryan Phillips | Government Official (2) |
| Jefferson Friedman | Tigerclaw Keyboard Player (2) |
| Jerry Lambert | General Rawson 'John' McCarthy (2) |
| Timothy E. Goodwin | |
| Nathan Donnelly | Boy Camper (2) |
| Kim Ramage | Student (2) |
| Baron Jay | Lawyer (2) |
| Zach Helmly | Zach (2) |
| Maari Tommon | Customer (2) |
| Gary Kraus | Glen Jarvis (2) |
| Brenda Ballard | Lucille (2) |
| Sophia Ziskin | Electro-City Governor (2) |
| Chris A. Liscomb | |
| Christina Lee | Reporter #3 (2) |
| Sean Patrick Bailey | |
| Bruce Greenwood | Bill Martinson (2) |
| Melanie Price | Mennonite Wedding Guest (2) |
| Jonathan Cargill | Mennonite Wedding Guest (2) |
| Cesar Torgersen-Davila | Bell Ringer (2) |
| Tom Simmons | Priest (2) |
| Barbie B. Lange | Student (2) |
| Jack Abrams | Camper (2) |
| Missy Yager | Christine (2) |
| Morgan Parsons | Amy's Friend (2) |
| Alexandra Moore | Singing Counselor #3 (2) |
| Gabriel Millman | Head Punk (2) |
| Jeremy Lucas | Singing Counselor #2 (2) |
| Aleksandra Kovacevic | Dummy Counselor (2) |
| Aisha Hinds | Amelia (2) |
| Samuel Goldman | Ventriloquist Counselor (2) |
| Christopher Cusumano | Medieval Punk (2) |
| Rozzi Crane | Lisa (2) |
| Kevin Thomas Conroy | Mork Punk (2) |
| Sarah Casolaro | Singing Counselor #1 (2) |
| Kathryn Burns | Dancing Counselor (2) |
| Madeline Blue | Cure Punk (2) |
| Richard Schiff | Dean Fairchild (2) |
| Kerri Kenney | |
| Rob Huebel | Brodfard Gilroy (2) |
| Rochelle Warner | Pres. Reagan's Secretary (2) |
| Adam Dorsey | Jd (2) |
| Morgan Womack | Kitchen Worker (2) |
| Tina Grimm | Camp Counselor (2) |