| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Ben Ahlers | Jack Treacher (25) Jack Trotter |
| Taylor Richardson | Bridget (26) |
| Kelli O'Hara | Aurora Fane (26) |
| Debra Monk | Armstrong (26) |
| Celia Keenan-Bolger | Mrs. Bruce (18) Bruce (8) |
| Douglas Sills | Monsieur Baudin (24) |
| Patrick Page | Richard Clay (25) |
| Christine Baranski | Agnes Van Rhijn (25) Agnes van Rhijn (25) |
| Cynthia Nixon | Ada Brook (25) |
| Jack Gilpin | Church (17) Mr. Church (8) |
| Simon Jones | Bannister (9) Mr. Bannister (8) Alfred Bannister (8) |
| Blake Ritson | Oscar Van Rhijn (25) Oscar van Rhijn (25) |
| Harry Richardson | Larry Russell (25) |
| Taissa Farmiga | Gladys Russell (25) |
| Denée Benton | Peggy Scott (25) |
| Louisa Jacobson | Marian Brook (25) |
| Morgan Spector | George Russell (25) |
| Carrie Coon | Bertha Russell (25) |
| Kristine Nielsen | Mrs. Bauer (17) Bauer (8) |
| Kelley Curran | Turner (8) Enid Turner (16) |
| Erin Wilhelmi | Adelheid (22) Adelheid Weber (17) |
| John Douglas Thompson | Arthur Scott (19) |
| Thomas Cocquerel | Tom Raikes (17) |
| Michael Cerveris | Watson (16) |
| Ward Horton | Charles Fane (16) |
| Audra McDonald | Dorothy Scott (15) |
| Donna Murphy | Mrs. Astor (6) Lina Astor (8) |
| Nathan Lane | Ward McAllister (12) |
| Rebecca Haden | Flora McNeil (12) |
| Ashlie Atkinson | Mamie Fish (12) |
| Sullivan Jones | T. Thomas Fortune (4) Thomas Fortune (8) |
| Ben Lamb | Duke of Buckingham (4) Hector Vere (8) |
| Amy Forsyth | Caroline 'Carrie' Astor (6) Carrie Astor (5) |
| Wes Meserve | Footman (9) |
| David Furr | Dashiell Montgomery (8) |
| William Ryall | Mr. Hefty (7) |
| Robert Sean Leonard | Matthew Forte (7) |
| Claybourne Elder | John Adams (6) |
| Jeanne Tripplehorn | Sylvia Chamberlain (6) |
| Katie Finneran | Anne Morris (6) |
| Matilda Lawler | Frances Montgomery (6) |
| Shawn Hopseker | Core Wealthy Business Man (5) |
| Zuzanna Szadkowski | Mabel Ainsley (5) |
| Nicole Brydon Bloom | Maud Beaton (5) |
| Jeremy Shamos | Mr. Gilbert (5) |
| Dakin Matthews | Joshua Winterton (4) |
| Christopher Denham | Robert McNeil (4) |
| Claybourne Elder | John Adams (4) |
| Rachel Pickup | Lady's Maid Miss André (3) |
| Laura Benanti | Susan Blane (3) |
| Merritt Wever | Monica O'Brien (2) |
| Bob Leszczak | Crash Photographer (2) Flag Hanger |
| John Sanders | Stanford White (3) |
| Linda Emond | Clara Barton (3) |
| Craig Geraghty | Griffin (3) |
| James Riordan | Dr. Lewis (3) |
| Darren Goldstein | Henderson (3) |
| Melanie Nicholls-King | Sarah J. Garnet (3) |
| Matt Walker | Billy Carlton (3) |
| Bill Camp | JP Morgan (3) |
| Jessica Frances Dukes | Athena Trumbo (3) |
| Brian Mitchell | Frederick Kirkland (3) |
| Phylicia Rashad | Elizabeth Kirkland (3) |
| Rebecca Radisic | Upscale Ball Guest Duke's Dinner Guest |
| Davis Wayne | Male Quadrille Dancer (2) |
| Raynor Rubel | Male Quadrille Dancer (2) |
| Evan Kinnane | Male Quadrille Dancer (2) |
| Joshua Burrage | Male Quadrille Dancer (2) |
| Melanie Moore | Sally Drexel (2) |
| Kylie Victoria Edwards | Angela Schermerhorn (2) |
| James Clow | Chamberlain House Butler (2) |
| Sandra Caldwell | Ellen (2) |
| Katherine Romans | Cissie Bingham (2) |
| Seth Sanford | NYPD Officer / Sheriff (2) |
| Nick Ziobro | McNeil Footman (2) |
| Henry Stram | Lewis (2) |
| Brian Keane | Brand (2) |
| Barbra Wengerd | Dressmaker (2) |
| Brooke Bloom | Miss Grant (2) |
| Michael Gill | Patrick Morris (2) |
| Marcella Lentz-Pope | Additional Voices (2) |
| Robert Loftus | Upper Class Spectator Smartly Dressed Man #3 |
| Peter Bradbury | Jay Gould (2) |
| Tony Carlin | Tritton (2) |
| Rebecca Haden | Flora McNeil (2) |
| Sarah Joy Miller | Christina Nilsson (2) |
| Fergie L. Philippe | James (2) |
| Lianne Marie Dobbs | Mrs. Henderson (2) |
| Brittany Bradford | Fannie Washington (2) |
| Josh Tobin | Mr. West (2) |
| Michael Braugher | Booker T. Washington (2) |
| David Wilson Barnes | Norman Tate (2) |
| Mark Boyett | Crowther (2) |
| Michael Burrell | Peter Barnes (2) |
| Liz Wisan | Emily Warren Roebling (2) |
| Will Connolly | Curate (2) |
| Andy Grotelueschen | Mr. Hastings (2) |
| Victoria Clark | Joan Carlton (2) |
| Bobby Steggert | John Singer Sargent (2) |
| Andrea Martin | Madame Dashkova (2) |
| Hattie Morahan | Lady Sarah Vere Sarah Vere |
| Paul Alexander Nolan | Alfred Merrick (2) |
| Stephen Carlile | Mr. Dobbs (2) |
| John Ellison Conlee | Weston (2) |
| Cher Lynn | Female Hired Help in Kitchen |
| Alec Varcas | Waltz Dancer |
| Dee Tomasetta | Waltz Dancer |
| Daniel Reardon | Waltz Dancer |
| Alex Nordin | Waltz Dancer |
| Weston Krukow | Waltz Dancer |
| Eric Anthony Johnson | Waltz Dancer |
| Jill Gittleman | Waltz Dancer |
| Lauren Gibbs | Waltz Dancer |
| Kaitlyn Frank | Waltz Dancer |
| David Ferguson | Waltz Dancer |
| Tenealle Farragher | Waltz Dancer |
| Leigh-Ann Esty | Waltz Dancer |
| Mia Deweese | |
| Nicholas Burrage | Waltz Dancer |
| Amanda Braun | Waltz Dancer |
| Christina Belinsky | Waltz Dancer |
| Nika Antuanette | Waltz Dancer |
| Chip Abbott | Waltz Dancer |
| Caleb Dicke | Russell Ball Footman |
| Anne-Marie Cusson | Mrs. Cuyper |
| Florrie Bagel | Academy of Music Singer |
| Hans Tester | Charron |
| Stephen Spinella | Julius Cuyper |
| Jacob Keith Watson | John Dixon |
| Paul Slade Smith | Union Club Waiter |
| Conan McCarty | Judge |
| Katherine Laheen | Bloomingdales Assistant |
| Christopher Harrod | Prosecutor |
| John Carrafa | Dancing Master |
| Nancy Kathryn Anderson | |
| Mark A. Langston | Stanford White's Architect |
| The Excelsior Cornet Band | Band |
| Mat Hostetler | Thomas Edison |
| Christopher Higgins | Russell House Footman |
| Christopher Gurr | Man at The Times |
| Iván Amaro Bullón | Inspector |
| Robert Lee Harvey | Cab Driver |
| Tim Eliot | Photographer |
| Ry Armstrong | Russell House Footman |
| Ken Allen Neely | Fane House Footman |
| David Harrell | Civil War Vet |
| Brenda Wehle | Mrs. Armstrong |
| Tom Blyth | Archie Baldwin |
| Sherry Cole | Upscale Fashionable Lady |
| Jonathan Spivey | Senior Manager |
| Liz McCartney | Female Spectator |
| Micaela Diamond | Shop Assistant |
| Peter Crouse | Male Spectator |
| Michael Luwoye | George Parker |
| Lisa Howard | Mrs. Henry Schermerhorn |
| Christopher Paul | Man on Bench |
| Cal McMenemy | Fane Footman |
| Christopher McLinden | Publishing House Secretary |
| Bill Irwin | Cornelius Eckhard |
| Michael Countryman | Carlton |
| Blanca Harnett | Bazaar Patron |
| Christopher Gullo | Pedestrian Walking Past Horse Drawn Cab |
| Aidan Christman | Newsboy |
| Blair Ross | Grand Woman |
| Desi Oakley | Miss Wavell |
| Kevin McCormick | Menacing Man |
| Andrew Youngerman | Construction Worker |
| Josh Mowery | Upscale Wealthy Man |
| Scott Montgomery | Dock Worker |
| Ken Holmes | Doylestown Auction Goer |
| Tim Halvorsen | Teen / Messenger Boy |
| Lenny Grossman | Meat Delivery Man |
| Madeleine Dee | Upscale Funeral Party Member |
| Mick o'Rourke | Shoved Man |
| Frank Alfano | |
| Jake Eavey | Fighting Man |
| Dared Wright | Kowalski |
| Ben Van Bergen | Fish House Butler |
| Stephanie Ittleson | Seamstress |
| Carolyn Holding | Helen Astor |
| John Hedges | Conductor |
| Ryan Halsaver | Cab Driver |
| Clark Carmichael | Porter at Train Station |
| Billy Beyrer | Terminal Porter |
| Ron Raines | John Thorburn |
| Michael Braugher | Booker T. Washington |
| Naomi Castellano | Church Servant |
| Mikayla Petrilla | Female Church-Goer |
| Teren Carter | Waiter |
| Thomas E Johnson | Male Church Goer |
| Tyler Magnis | Roebling Footman |
| Francis McGinny | Tennis Player |
| Gavin DiFranco | Footman ND |
| Geoffrey Murphy | General |
| Rebecca Watson | Headmistress |
| Lennart Nielsen | Servant |
| Sophia Adler | Lillie Langtry |
| Brian Hutchison | Mason Sturt |
| Alex Michell | Male Student |
| John Ford-Dunker | Other Man |
| Austin Jennings Boykin | Union Man #1 |
| Ryan Perez | Union Man 2 |
| Dawn McGee | Sally |
| Benjamin Magnuson | Indegent Man |
| Laughton Royce | Isaiah |
| J. T. O'Connor | Security Guard |
| Frank Ridley | Mr. Whitmore |
| James Hindman | Mr. Schubert |
| Charles Everett | Parent |
| Dan Matteucci | Waiter |
| Jordan Mahome | Samuel Spring |
| Gregory Dann | Barman |
| Don Clark Williams | Pastor |
| Julie Dawn Parrell | Kitchen Maid |
| LaTonya Borsay | Grandmother Spring |
| John Behlmann | Edward Morgan |
| Michael Halling | Dashiell's Friend |
| Jordan Waller | Oscar Wilde |
| Michael Burrell | Peter Barnes |
| Josh Davis | Mill Leader |
| Todd A. Horman | Mill Leader |
| Sean-Michael Wilkinson | Footman |
| David T. Patterson | Prince Alexis |
| Samantha Sturm | Vera |
| Sophia Adler | Lillie Langtry |
| Michael Di Liberto | Organizer |
| Jonathan Fielding | Journalist |
| Fred Inkley | Mr. Thompson |
| James Mount | Journalist |
| David Newer | Butler |
| Audrey Bennett | Nora |
| Julia Coffey | Mrs. Glennie |
| Andy Ingalls | Mr. Harris |
| Adam Monley | John Burns |
| Madison Skye Validum | Murphy |
| Lennart Nielsen | Servant |
| Edgar Sebastian | Student |
| K. Scott Warren | Choir Director |
| Michael Di Liberto | Organizer |
| Amber Gray | Gloria Valentine |
| Khamary Rose | David Sturt |
| Jesse Sharp | Schneider |
| Phillip Goodwin | Dr. Sanders |
| Kathy McCafferty | Miss Frost |
| Dawn McGee | Sally |
| Jeanna de Waal | Miss Higgins |
| Nicole Van Giesen | Miss Freeman |
| John Ford-Dunker | Other Man |
| Tabatha Gayle | Female Student |
| Alex Michell | Male Student |
| Travis Przybylski | Roebling Footman |
| Jes Washington | Elizabeth |
| Nell Enfield | Malcolm Keene |
| Chad Ackerman | Commanding Officer |
| Mark Bedard | Manager |
| Austin Jennings Boykin | Union Man |
| Frank Bradford | Militia Captain |
| Cameron Dickson | Henderson's Son |
| Ryan M. Pérez | Union Man |
| Benjamin Magnuson | Indigent Man |
| Kevin Dennis | Mr. Roebling |
| Kevin Hogan | Butler |
| Emilie Kouatchou | Mabel |
| Gannon McHale | Mr. Harcourt |
| Richmond Hoxie | Head of the Board |
| Charles Everett | Emmett |
| Lachlan Quertermous | Russell House Footman |
| Jade Radford | Betsy |
| Laughton Royce | Isaiah |
| Harry Smith | Patrick Ryan |
| Rufus Collins | Second Mine Owner |
| Clemmie Evans | Temperance Woman |
| Sean Jeanness | Morenci Man |
| Caitlin O'Connell | Mrs. Graves |
| Lisa Gay Hamilton | Frances Ellen Watkins Harper |
| Leslie Uggams | Ernestine Brown |
| Ken Land | Arterton |
| Andrew Garman | Mr. Delancey |
| Marilyn Child | Clockmaker |
| Brenda McCullough | Loretta |
| Roya Shanks | Mrs. Delancey |
| Dorcas Sowunmi | Louise |
| Andrew Haserlat | Clock Secretary |
| Garret Long | Shop Woman |
| David Manis | Bishop |
| Tommy Schrider | Mr. Eldridge |