| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Juno Temple | Bettye McCartt (10) |
| Giovanni Ribisi | Joe Colombo (10) |
| Colin Hanks | Barry Lapidus (10) |
| Burn Gorman | Charles Bluhdorn (10) |
| Dan Fogler | Francis Ford Coppola (10) |
| Matthew Goode | Robert Evans (10) |
| Miles Teller | Albert S. Ruddy (10) |
| Frank Moschetto | Gambino Worker (10) |
| Jake Cannavale | Caesar (9) |
| Josh Zuckerman | Peter Bart (8) |
| Lou Ferrigno | Lenny Montana (8) |
| Anthony Ippolito | Al Pacino (7) |
| Meredith Autry | Ali MacGraw (7) |
| Patrick Gallo | Mario Puzo (6) |
| Anthony Skordi | Carlo Gambino (6) |
| Joey Russo | 'Crazy' Joe Gallo (6) |
| Annie Funke | Sheila (5) |
| T. J. Thyne | |
| Eric Balfour | Dean Tavoularis (5) |
| Paul McCrane | Jack Ballard (5) |
| Tracy Silver | Bluhdorn's Secretary (3) Bluhdorn Secretary (2) |
| John Fantasia | Gambino Made Guy (5) |
| James Madio | Gino (5) |
| Justin Chambers | Marlon Brando (4) |
| Zack Schor | Fred Gallo (4) |
| Derrick Baskin | Nicky Barnes (4) |
| Frank John Hughes | Frank Sinatra (4) |
| Danny Nucci | Congressman Mario Biaggi (4) |
| Stephanie Koenig | Andrea Eastman (4) |
| Louis Fasanaro | Gambino (4) Gambino Made Guy |
| Nora Arnezeder | Francoise Glazer (4) |
| Carmine Giovinazzo | Sonny Grosso (2) |
| Kirk Acevedo | Special Agent Hale |
| Derek Richardson | Mitch Kaufman |
| Billy Magnussen | Robert Redford |
| Lola Glaudini | Candida Donadio |
| Brandon Sklenar | Burt Reynolds |
| Jared Boyd Miller | Makeup Artist (3) |
| Michael Jovanovski | Camera Operator (3) |
| Branden Williams | Gianni Russo (3) |
| Michael Rispoli | Tommy Lucchese (3) |
| Geoffrey Arend | Aram Avakian (3) |
| Seth Vernon | Artist (3) |
| Nicole Alicia Xavier | Hollywood Starlet (3) |
| George Scro | Paramount Executive Paramount Executed |
| Loren Marie Marino | Italian Wife - Angelo's Restaurant Italian Woman |
| Christopher Wallinger | Agent Zabel (2) |
| Cynthia Aileen Strahan | Talia Shire (2) |
| George Russo | Paul Sciacci (2) |
| Nick Pupo | John Cazale (2) |
| Matt Gottlieb | Phillip 'Benny Squint' Lombardo (2) |
| Elliot Gannon | Production Assistant (2) |
| Damian Conrad | James Caan (2) |
| Mark Berry | Agent Richman (2) |
| Derek Magyar | Robert Duvall (2) |
| Christian Roberts | Italian League Reporter #3 (2) |
| Turhan Caylak | Richard 'Dickie' Dunston (2) |
| Maya Butler | Diane Keaton (2) |
| Shannon Corbett | Secretary (2) |
| Joe Marinelli | Peter Lovano (2) |
| Vincent Lionetti | Gambino Made Guy (2) |
| Ron Roggé | Jilly Rizzo (2) |
| Lavinia Postolache | Young Beauty (2) |
| Robbie Martin | Peter Bogdanovich |
| Michelle Ghatan | Theatre Patron |
| Mikel Farber | SFX Guy |
| Johnny Venocur | Mobster #2 |
| Joe Vassallo | Saro Vitelli |
| Kenneth Simmons | Mobster #1 |
| Tony Robinette | Eugene Vault |
| Sebastiano Pigazzi | Angelo Vitelli |
| Eric Mitro | |
| Chad McCord | Editor |
| Allen Marsh | Alvin Sargent |
| Sandro Iocolano | AD Tony Venezia |
| Vincent Giovanni | Bruno |
| Vito D'Ambrosio | |
| Sole Bovelli | Simonetta |
| Juan Antonio Bolivar | Corleone Waiter |
| Jonathan Biver | Marketing Executive #1 |
| Kourosh Parsapour | Colombo Guard |
| Keri Jenzer | Wrap Party Dancer |
| Kelly Frydman | Wrap Party Dancer |
| Bryan Friday | Gallo Soldier #1 |
| Bennie Arthur | Dick Smith |
| Anthony Aldapa | White Hat Guy |
| Jacob Taylor | Police Officer |
| Veronica Wylie | Seamstress |
| Ian Michaels | Robert Towne |
| Rio Magdaleno | Salesman |
| Kenny Barr | Stunt Coordinator |
| Meredith VanCuyk | Mob Wife |
| Jenly Crespo | Upscale Lounge Guest |
| Kevin Czako | Colombo Member |
| John Mariano | Anthony Spirachio |
| Lynn Adrianna | Madolina Colombo |
| Lauren Bond | Lynn |
| Jennifer Bond | Mary |
| Jack Bennett | Mob Butcher |
| Aimee Carrero | Rosie Molina |
| Danielle Titus | Script Supervisor |
| Brittney Baxter | Polo Lounge |
| Andrew Pickwood | Tea Room Waiter |
| Christian Pedersen | Gary Glynn |
| Anthony Gruppuso | Mafia Soldier |
| Aarón Alonso | Gaffer |
| Michael Gandolfini | Andy Calhoun |
| Holly Traister | Funeral Guest |
| Michaela Rances | Polo Lounge Patron |
| Taissa Zveiter | Carmine's Wife |
| Christopher Wolfe | Italian League Reporter #1 |
| O'Shay Neal | Jamar Jackson |
| Dawn Joyal | Anna Johnstone |
| Charlie Heydt | Jim Aubrey |
| Lisa Dobbyn | Morgana King |
| Brian Carpenter | Italian League Reporter #2 |
| Jason Boegh | Polo Lounge Maitre'D |
| Emil Lawrence | Surveyor #1 |
| Blake Leon | God Father Diner |
| Colin Seifert | Kai Episode |
| Michael DeBartolo | Joe Colombo's Soldier |
| Ken Rudulph | |
| Duncan Bravo | Dr. Karam Singh |
| Mark Atteberry | Bill Thompson |
| Cheyenne Kizirian | Clerk 20's |
| Raelynn Harper | Escort |
| Amanda Fields | Congressman Biaggi's Woman |
| Johnno Wilson | Bartender |
| Corey Landis | Stan Kamen |
| Patrick Labyorteaux | Murray Miller |
| Mimi Gianopulos | Sue Mengers |
| Baker Wiles | Jet Pilot |
| Peter Lawrence Singer | Acapella Singer |
| Johnny Mansbach | Studio Director |
| Vincent Maldonado | Nightclub Guest |
| Casey Cathcart | Redford Knock-off |
| Maria Beltramini | Office Worker |
| Mary Aldousary | Hostess |
| Ted Monte | Anthony Coniglio |
| Corrin Evans | Amy |
| Dylynn Abbey | Kristy |
| Nathan Peterson | |
| Ross McCall | Moran |
| Louis Mandylor | Mickey Cohen |
| Michael Landes | Vic Damone |
| Nate Smith | Agent |
| Mark Roman | Executive |
| Amber Martinez | Party Guest |
| Danielle Lima | Mitch's Friend |
| Jordan Laesch | Liz Taylor's Assistant |
| Craig Jordan | Flower Delivery Guy |
| Tyler Hill | Butch Cassidy PA |
| Michael Heidemann | NYC Racetrack Patron |
| Saint Heart | Office Worker |
| Fair Micaela Griffin | Julie |
| Joseph W. Evans | NYC Race Track Patron |
| Christopher Collins | Junior Executive |
| Chris Aemond | Pedestrian |
| Jean Watts | Ann Margret |
| J. Winford Warren | Dave |
| Marcelo Tubert | Dominic Magnolia |
| Natasha Sill | Nancy |
| Marco Schiazza | Chasen's Maitre'D |
| Jake Regal | Arthur Hiller |
| Steven Pritchard | Ted |
| Ryan Krause | Johnny Actor |
| Paul Gunning | William Paley |
| Michael S. Garcia | Chateau Valet |
| Matthew Furfaro | |
| Cat Elliott | CBS Receptionist |
| Catherine Chapman | |
| Paul Black | Chateau Talent Agent |
| Kyle S. More | Bernie Fein |
| Sal Landi | Joe Bonnano |
| Victoria Kelleher | Erika Puzo |
| Erin Coker | Premiere Reporter #1 |
| Charlie Farrell | Reporter with Puzo |
| Jean-Christophe Febbrari | Jean Leon |
| Rick Gifford | Premiere Reporter #2 |
| Diane Mizota | Studio Reporter #1 |
| Nicholas Petroccione | |
| Dave Shalansky | Henry Kissinger |
| Aevrey Balin | Worker |
| Zack Carter | Oscars Attendee |
| James Espinosa | Theater Patron |
| Leanne Tarrab | Fan |
| Luke Matheis | Jack Nicholson |
| Sean Shea-Clark | Fan |
| Jack Trout | Prison Guard |
| Nick White | Premier Security |
| Michael Wittig | Guard |