| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Gloria Reuben | DA Mae Silver (20) |
| Ernie Hudson | Rev. Edwin Peters (20) |
| Maggie Lawson | Supt. Sarah Silver (20) |
| Donnie Wahlberg | Det. Danny Reagan (20) |
| Sonequa Martin | Det. Lena Silver (20) |
| Marcus Scribner | Ofc. Jonah Silver (20) |
| Mika Amonsen | Ofc. Sean Reagan (20) |
| Marisa Ramirez | Maria Baez (4) |
| Mike Vogel | Seth Yates (3) |
| Bridget Moynahan | Erin Reagan (2) |
| Ryan Broussard | Detective Brian Rodgers (2) |
| Brian Goodman | Mayor Jim Shaw |
| Kenric Green | Charlie (2) |
| Xochitl Gomez | Penelope 'Penny' Bravo (2) |
| Joel de la Fuente | Bobby Mullins |
| Bernard Wagner | Joanna Daniels |
| Carolyn McCormick | Winnie Malakov |
| Len Cariou | Henry Reagan |
| Laura Kai Chen | Officer Sylvia Min |
| Chad Camilleri | Harold Baca |
| Anastasia Barzee | Naomi Ballard |
| Adam Kolozsvari | Rory Flynn |
| Tom Costello | Detective Mike Betts |
| Jonathan Koensgen | Patrick 'Sully' Sullivan |
| Steven Pigozzo | Det. Keith Ward |
| Matia Jackett | Phoebe Yates |
| Callum Shoniker | Michael Flynn |
| Braxton Fannin | Jimmy Holloway |
| Mark MacRae | Denzel |