| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Gemma Hoskins | Self - Investigator (7) |
| Abbie Schaub | Self - Investigator (7) |
| Virginia Anzengruber | Cinematic Sequences (7) |
| Jean Hargadon Wehner | Self - Jane Doe (6) |
| Sister Cathy Cesnik | Self - Murder Victim (5) |
| Teresa Lancaster | Self - Former Student (4) Self - Jane Roe |
| Tom Nugent | Self - Journalist (5) |
| Bob Erlandson | Self - Journalist (4) |
| Gerry Koob | Self - Former Priest (4) |
| Chris Centofanti | Self - Former Student (3) |
| Lil Hughes Knipp | Self - Former Student (3) |
| Donna Vondenbosch | Self - Former Student (3) |
| Patricia Gilner | Self - Former Nun (3) |
| Beverly Wallace | Self - Attorney (3) |
| Marilyn Cesnik | Self - Sister Cathy's Sister (3) |
| Kelly Pendygraft | Sister Cathy Cesnik (2) |
| Deb Silcox | Self - Former Student (2) |
| Mary Spence | Self - Former Student (2) |
| Don Malecki | Self - Joyce's Brother (2) |
| Darryl Malecki | Self - Joyce's Brother (2) |
| Pat Malecki | Self - Joyce's Brother (2) |
| John Barnold | Self - Former Captain, Baltimore City Police (2) |
| James Scannell | Self - Former Captain, Baltimore County Police (2) |
| Alan Horn | Self - Investigator (2) |
| Ginger Horne | Cinematic Sequences (2) |
| Ed Hargadon | Self - Jean's Brother (2) |
| Mike Hargadon | Self - Jean's Brother (2) |
| Don Hargadon | Self - Jean's Brother (2) |
| Bob Hargadon | Self - Jean's Brother (2) |
| Ethel Hargadon | Self - Jean's Mother (2) |
| Kathy Hobeck | Self - Former Student (2) |
| Brian Schwaab | Self - Former Detective, Baltimore City Police (2) |
| Cecelia Wambach | Self - Former Nun (2) |
| Michael Wehner | Self - Jean's Husband (2) |
| Sarah Wehner | Self - Jean's Daughter (2) |
| L.M. Lothstein | Self - Former Director of Psychology, Institute of Living Self - Yale University |
| Sharon A.H. May | Self - State's Attorney's Office (2) |
| Kevin Murphy | Self - Archdiocese Attorney Self - Attorney for the Maryland Catholic Conference |
| Margaret | Self - Debbie's Aunt Self - Edgar's First Wife |
| Barbara Schmidt | Self - Bill Schmidt's Relative Self - Sharon's Mother |
| Edgar Davidson | Self - Suspect (2) |
| Gary Childs | Self - Baltimore County Police (2) |
| Diane Koob | Self - Gerry's Wife (2) |
| Victoria Van Fleet | Lil Hughes Knepp |
| Juliana Farrell | Self - Former Student |
| Joyce Malecki | Self - Murder Victim |
| Lyn Smith | Self - Former Nun |
| Pat Potter | Self - Former Student |
| Greg Wehner | Self - Jean's Son |
| Helen Hargadon | Self - Jean's Sister |
| Val Hargadon | Self - Jean's Sister-in-Law |
| Deep Throat | Self - Informant |
| Lee Richmond | Self - Loyola University |
| Randy Lancaster | Self - Teresa's Husband |
| Michael Lehane | Self - Maskell's Attorney |
| Paul McHugh | Self - Director, John Hopkins Department of Psychiatry |
| Werner Spitz | Self - Forensic Pathologist |
| Christian Richter | Self - Doctor |
| Richard Sipe | Self - Former Priest, Department of Psychiatry, John Hopkins |
| Tom Harrison | Self - Attorney for SSND |
| Debbie Yohn | Self - Edgar Davidson's Niece |
| Bill Yohn | Self - Debbie's Husband |
| Sharon Schmidt | Self - Billy Schmidt's Niece |
| Gary Lester | Self - Gemologist |
| Brian Schmidt | Self - Witness |
| Jerry Turner | Self - News Reporter |
| Bud Roemer | Self - Detective |
| Robin Teal | Self - Baltimore County Police |
| Charles Franz | Self - Former Student |
| Bob Radakovic | Self - Marilyn's Husband |
| C.T. Wilson | Self - Maryland State Delegate |
| Fran Bacon | Self - Survivor |
| David Lorenz | Self - Survivor |
| Jamie Raskin | Self - Maryland State Senator |
| Alison D'Alessandro | Self - Archdiocesan Director of Child & Youth Protection |
| Sean T. Caine | Self - Vice Chancellor, Archdiocese of Baltimore |