| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Diedrich Bader | Elliot Tompkins (7) |
| Michael Landes | Tom (6) Tom Harper |
| Alexandra Breckenridge | Carly McKenna (7) |
| Heather Burns | Jenna Dennings (7) |
| Anne Heche | Beth Harper (7) |
| Madison Davenport | Emily Harper (7) |
| Stephen Schneider | Pete Dennings (7) |
| Jeffrey Wadlington | Pizza CHef (7) |
| Joy Osmanski | Maggie Tompkins (6) |
| Betty White | God |
| Renee Elise Goldsberry | Mary |
| Orlando Jones | God #2 |
| Brianne Tju | Riley (3) |
| Mark Parrish | Pizza Chef (3) |
| Jessica Lundy | Victoria (2) |
| Debra Mooney | Ruby |
| Jane Cho | Woman #2 |
| Oliver Vaquer | Man |
| David Bottrell | Brian |
| Harry Murphy | Pastor Jim |
| Dan Sachoff | Chris Stackie |
| Duane R. Shepard Sr. | Ben |
| Alfred Dennis | Old Man |
| Debra Wilson | Stephanie |
| Rebecca Grant | Tiffany Melrose |
| Dylan Minnette | Ben Tompkins |
| Rizwan Manji | Dr. Carroll |
| Anjali Bhimani | Dr. Malikay |
| Jane Galloway Heitz | Meg |
| Steve Mallory | Security Guard |
| Donnell Turner | Benicio |
| Stephanie K. Grant | Tween #1 |
| Burl Moseley | Todd |
| Hannah Payne | Rachel |
| Chris Lusti | Suburban Dad |
| Elizabeth Schmidt | Dana |
| Bonnie-Kathleen Discepolo | Partygoer |
| Exie Booker | Harrison |
| Tammy Felice | Woman |
| Kristen De Luca | Destiny |
| Guilford Adams | Jeremy |
| Angela Matemotja | Cashier |
| Brandon J. Sornberger | Man |
| Michael McDonald | Randall |
| John Senese | Tad |
| Tajh Bellow | Ben Wilkins |
| Jhing | Church Choir Girl |
| Kristian Weathers | Mom |
| Armah 'Mr. G' David | Sous Chef |
| Ashleigh Biller | Lacrosse Player |
| Hannah Marie Sack | Little Beth |
| Stephen Todt | Scared Kid |
| Tessa Kraemer | Girl #1 |
| Ben Lomboy | Patient |
| Pete Williams | Guy #1 |
| Desiree Proctor | Rosie |
| Nehemiah Sutton | Andre |