| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Jessica Biel | Candy Montgomery (5) |
| Melanie Lynskey | Betty Gore (5) |
| Raul Esparza | Don Crowder (5) |
| Pablo Schreiber | Allan Gore (5) |
| Sharon Morris | Sandra Lockett (4) Sandra |
| Timothy Simons | Pat Montgomery (5) |
| Jessie Mueller | Sherry Cleckler (5) |
| Coley Campany | Linda (5) |
| Aven Lotz | Becky Montgomery (5) |
| Dash McCloud | Jason Montgomery (5) |
| Jamie Anne Allman | Elaine (4) |
| Antonella Rose | Christina Gore (4) |
| Jason Ritter | Deputy Denny Reese (2) |
| Tim Ware | Judge Ryan (3) |
| Russell Thomas | Jeffery Lockett (2) Jeffrey Lockett |
| Justin Timberlake | Deffibaugh (2) |
| Jack Landry | Tom Cleckler (2) |
| Adam Bartley | Richard (2) |
| Bruce McKinnon | Jerry (2) |
| Rick Espaillat | Bob Pomeroy (2) |
| Jose Miguel Vasquez | Lester Gayler (2) |
| Annie Cook | Mrs. Pomeroy (2) |
| Jordan Patrick | Reverend Ron (2) |
| Jesse Gallegos | Robert Udashen (2) |
| Jaclyn White | Spectator Journalist News reporter (2) |
| Kevin Brown | Allan's Co-worker (2) |
| Jason Davis | Jack Barton |
| Preston James Hillier | Chuck |
| Sunkrish Bala | Sid |
| Elisabeth Lewis Corley | Don's Mother |
| Lauren Halperin | Tommy |
| Jayson Warner Smith | DA O'Connell |
| Luis R. Hernandez | Allan's Boss |
| Aaron K Smalls | News Anchor |
| Robert Mello | Earl |
| Selena Anduze | Jackie Ponder |
| Shaun Michael Lynch | Deputy Dave |
| Liz McGeever | Mary Lou Barton |
| Tom Nacy Warner | Psychiatrist |
| Jay D. Kacho | Juror #2 |
| Javier Vazquez Jr. | Jury Foreman |
| Mallory Hoff | Journalist |
| Jaci Ruffley | Church Member |
| Sara Lynn Herman | Waitress |
| Norio Nishimura | ADA Schultz |
| Ed Sturdivant | Allan's Friend |
| Hudson Hughes | Davey |
| Billie Roy | Kimmy |
| Alex Mitchell | DFW Bank Teller |
| Daniel Pransky | Desk Clerk |
| Peyton Waldrep | Girl |
| Katherine Barnes | Mother |
| Madison Bello | Young Candy |
| Leanny L Lopez | Spectator |