| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Megan Henning | Monica Shaw (6) |
| Cleo King | Francine Hill (6) |
| Randy Quaid | Chief Hank Shaw (6) |
| John Carroll Lynch | Mayor Garrett Shaw (6) |
| Chris Penn | Waylon Shaw (6) |
| Mare Winningham | Dottie Shaw (6) |
| Elizabeth McGovern | Helen Shaw (6) |
| Ann Cusack | Julie Shaw (6) |
| Angela Goethals | Katie Shaw (6) |
| Larry Miller | Scott Haggis (4) |
| Romy Rosemont | Andrea Morris |
| Sabrina Wiese | Waitress (3) |
| Jeff D'Agostino | Malcom Shaw (3) |
| Gil McKinney | Joel Nudnick (2) |
| Andy Morrow | Peter (2) |
| Richard Ruccolo | Charlie Babbot (2) |
| Jayne Taini | Sylvie Hump (2) |
| T.J. Beacom | |
| Elizabeth Sampson | Sharon Ropers (2) |
| Joel McCrary | Carney (2) |
| Patrick Kerr | Hootie Howell (2) |
| Lynette DuPree | Assistant |
| Paul Michael Bloodgood | Aerobics Dancer |
| Lindsay Zir | Aerobics Instructor |
| Robert Stanton | Dr. Patz |
| Deborah Ouellette | Auditioning Singer |
| Susan Lay | Waitress |
| Harry Murphy | Walter Kremmling |
| Jim Jackman | Roger Moshen |
| Hayden Bromberg | Young Waylon Shaw |
| George Newbern | Boyle |
| Jodi Benson | Choir soloist |
| Bernard Kuby | |
| Rod Lundgren | Congregant |
| William Russ | Reverend Deeker |
| Terrence Beasor | John |
| Hannah Cornett | Tara |
| D.J. Harner | Terry |
| Priscilla Leona Horne | Townsperson |
| Josh Jacobson | Danny |
| Lynn Ann Leveridge | Mary |
| Patrick O'Connell | Kevin Benson |
| Robin Sydney | Maddie Morris |