| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Susanna Thompson | Judith Webster (8) |
| Aidan Quinn | Daniel Webster (8) |
| Cheryl White | Victoria Conlin (8) |
| Fran Bennett | Rainy (8) |
| Ellen Burstyn | Bishop Beatrice Congreve (8) |
| Dylan Baker | Roger Paxton (8) |
| Garret Dillahunt | Jesus Christ (8) |
| Alison Pill | Grace Webster (8) |
| Ivan Shaw | Adam Webster (8) |
| Christian Campbell | Peter Webster (8) Peter Webster / Jimmy Webster |
| James Rebhorn | Bertram Webster (6) |
| Leven Rambin | Caroline Paxton (5) |
| Gillian Jacobs | Adele Congreve (5) |
| D.W. Moffett | Worth Webster (4) |
| John Driscoll | David Congreve (4) |
| Marco Barricelli | Tony Vaporelli (4) |
| Daniel Mastrogiorgio | Michael Vaporelli (4) |
| Laila Robins | Nora Paxton (4) |
| Kathleen Chalfant | Catherine Webster (4) |
| Dan Hedaya | Father Frank (4) |
| Alana De La Garza | Jessie Gilmore (3) |
| Enver Gjokaj | Josh (2) |
| Gaius Charles | Carver |
| Fredric Lehne | |
| Kat Foster | Michelle Hedley |
| Christopher Evan Welch | Scott Clarkson |
| Jonah Meyerson | Yoda (3) |
| Celia Allen | Dinner Guest Restaurant Diner Parish Member |
| Alice Playten | Francesca (2) |
| Scott William Winters | |
| Robert Clohessy | Billy (2) |
| Barbara Marineau | Gloria (2) |
| Kaija Matiss | Becky (2) |
| Edward M. Kelahan | Church Parishioner (2) |
| Gail Yudain | Parish Member (2) |
| John Pankow | Charlie Conlin (2) |
| Kelly Hu | Kristine Ho (2) |
| Chazz Menendez | Stunt Thug #2 |
| Brian Murray | Boy in Ice Cream Shop |
| Paul Quinn | Arthur |
| Lynn Whitfield | Elena |
| Nathan Peck | Keith |
| Christopher R. Bugg | Teen Clerk |
| Brian O'Neill | Detective Lansing |
| John E. Mack | Stunt Thug #3 |
| Marcus Collins | Server |
| Jay Spece | Waiter |
| John Scurti | Detective |
| Pierre Epstein | Doctor |
| June Miller | Edith |
| Donna Murphy | Dr. Libby Webster |
| Heather Dispensa | Church goer |
| Marian Seldes | Grandma Helen |
| Libby George | Rosemary Bartlett |
| Dhonna Harris Goodale | Waitress |
| Eric Silver | Congregation Member #2 |
| Halley Wegryn Gross | Wanda |
| Lee Roy Rogers | Betty Stanley |
| Carolyn Kennedy | Church Patron |
| Mackenzie Connolly | Jeannie |
| David Rasche | Donald Warwick |
| David Harbour | Kevin Warwick |
| Audra Blaser | Vanessa Warwick |
| Laura Stepp | Joan Warwick |
| Tim Lamendola | Daniel's Caddy |
| Tandy Cronyn | Doris |
| Chris Vaughn | Church Parishioner |
| Jonathan Young | Churchgoer |
| Marin Hinkle | Nancy |