| Darsteller | Rolle |
|---|---|
| Kate Siegel | Erin Greene (7) |
| Kristin Lehman | Annie Flynn (7) |
| Samantha Sloyan | Bev Keane (7) |
| Igby Rigney | Warren Flynn (7) |
| Rahul Kohli | Sheriff Hassan (7) |
| Annarah Cymone | Leeza (7) |
| Annabeth Gish | Dr. Sarah Gunning (7) |
| Alexandra Essoe | Mildred Gunning (7) |
| Rahul Abburi | Ali Hassan (7) |
| Matt Biedel | Sturge (7) |
| Crystal Balint | Dolly (7) |
| Louis Oliver | Ooker (7) |
| Henry Thomas | Ed Flynn (7) |
| Hamish Linklater | Father Paul (7) |
| Andrew Grush | |
| Quinton Boisclair | Angel (5) Figure (2) Figure on the Beach |
| Zach Gilford | Riley Flynn (7) |
| Michael Trucco | Wade (7) |
| Ebony Booth | Tara-Beth (4) |
| Patricia Drake | Joanie (4) |
| Robert Longstreet | Joe Collie (4) |
| Carla Gugino | Judge |
| Vincent Gale | Howie Hobbs (3) |
| John C. MacDonald | Bowl (3) |
| Ese Atawo | Parishioner #2 (2) |
| Pasha Ebrahimi | Parishioner #1 (2) |
| Tanis Dolman | Hysterical Woman (2) |
| Mike Flanagan | Young Priest |
| Camille Atebe | Attractive Woman |
| Jaren Moore | AA Moderator |
| Marci T. House | Mainland Doctor |
| Michael Tiernan | Mailman |
| Kapila Rego | Lawyer |
| Lyza Ulrych | Victim's Mother |
| Anup Sehdev | Paramedic |